The use and misuse of biomarkers in ecotoxicology
Corresponding Author
Valery E. Forbes
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, DenmarkSearch for more papers by this authorAnnemette Palmqvist
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Search for more papers by this authorLis Bach
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Valery E. Forbes
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, DenmarkSearch for more papers by this authorAnnemette Palmqvist
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Search for more papers by this authorLis Bach
Department of Life Sciences and Chemistry, Roskilde University, Universitetsvej 1, P.O. Box 260, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Substantial efforts have been devoted to developing and applying biomarkers for use in ecotoxicology. These efforts have resulted partly from a desire for early warning indicators that respond before measurable effects on individuals and populations occur and partly as an aid to identifying the causes of observed population- and community-level effects. Whereas older biomarkers focused on measures of organism physiology or biochemistry, advances in molecular biology are extending the biomarker philosophy to the level of the genes (i.e., ecotoxicogenomics). However, the extent to which biomarkers are able to provide unambiguous and ecologically relevant indicators of exposure to or effects of toxicants remains highly controversial. In the present paper, we briefly discuss the application of biomarkers in ecotoxicology and ecological risk assessment, and we provide examples of how they have been applied. We conclude that although biomarkers can be helpful for gaining insight regarding the mechanisms causing observed effects of chemicals on whole-organism performance and may, in some cases, provide useful indicators of exposure, individual biomarker responses should not be expected to provide useful predictions of relevant ecological effects—and probably not even predictions of whole-organism effects. Suites of biomarkers are only likely to provide increased predictability if they can be used in a comprehensive mechanistic model that integrates them into a measure of fitness. Until this can be achieved, biomarkers may be useful for hypothesis generation in carefully controlled experiments. However, because the aims of environmental monitoring and ecological risk assessment are to detect and/or predict adverse chemical impacts on populations, communities, and ecosystems, we should be focusing our efforts on improving methods to do this directly. This will involve developing and testing models of appropriate complexity that can describe real-world systems at multiple scales.
REFERENCES
- 1 Huggett RJ, Kimerle RA, Mehrle PM Jr, Bergman HL. 2002. Biomarkers: Biochemical, Physiological, and Histological Markers of Anthropogenic Stress. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA.
- 2 Timbrell JA. 1998. Biomarkers in toxicology. Toxicology 129: 1–12.
- 3 JF McCarthy, LR Shugart, eds., 1990. Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA.
- 4
Peakall D.
1992.
Animal Biomarkers as Pollution Indicators.
Chapman & Hall, London, UK.
10.1007/978-94-011-2346-4 Google Scholar
- 5 Peakall D. 1994. Biomarkers—The way forward in environmental assessment. TEN 1: 55–60.
- 6 Nias DJ, McKillup SC, Edyvane KS. 1993. Imposex in Lepsiella vinosa from Southern Australia. Mar Pollut Bull 26: 380–384.
- 7 Evans SM, Kerrigan E, Palmer N. 2000. Causes of imposex in the dogwhelk Nucella lapillus (L.) and its use as a biological indicator of tributyltin contamination. Mar Pollut Bull 40: 212–219.
- 8 Matthiessen P, Gibbs PE. 1998. Critical appraisal of the evidence for tributyltin-mediated endocrine disruption in mollusks. Environ Toxicol Chem 17: 37–43.
- 9 Matthiessen P, Waldock R, Thain JE, Waite ME, Scrope-Howe S. 1995. Changes in periwinkle (Littorina littorea) populations following the ban on TBT-based antifoulings on small boats in the United Kingdom. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 30: 180–194.
- 10 Suter GW II. 1990. Use of biomarkers in ecological risk assessment. In JF McCarthy, LR Shugart, eds, Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA, pp 419–428.
- 11 Allen JI, Moore MN. 2004. Environmental prognostics: Is the current use of biomarkers appropriate for environmental risk evaluation? Mar Environ Res 58: 227–232.
- 12 Nesto N, Bertoldo M, Nasci C, Da Ros L. 2004. Spatial and temporal variation of biomarkers in mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) from the Lagoon of Venice, Italy. Mar Environ Res 58: 287–291.
- 13 Werner I, Teh SJ, Datta S, Lu XQ, Young TM. 2004. Biomarker responses in Macoma nasuta (Bivalvia) exposed to sediments from northern San Francisco Bay. Mar Environ Res 58: 299–304.
- 14 Pough FH. 1989. Organismal performance and Darwinian fitness: Approaches and interpretations. Physiol Zool 62: 199–236.
- 15 Malloy KD, Targett TE. 1994. The use of RNA:DNA ratios to predict growth limitation of juvenile summer flounder (Paralichthys dentatus) from Delaware and North Carolina estuaries. Mar Biol 118: 367–375.
- 16 Smith PN, Bandiera SM, Skipper SL, Johnson KA, McMurry ST. 2004. Environmental polychlorinated biphenyl exposure and cytochrome P450 in raccoons (Procyon lotor). Environ Toxicol Chem 22: 417–423.
- 17 Arts M-JSJ, Schill RO, Knigge T, Eckwert H, Kammenga JE, Köhler H-R. 2004. Stress proteins (hsp70, hsp60) induced in isopods and nematodes by field exposure to metals in a gradient near Avonmouth, UK. Ecotoxicology 13: 739–755.
- 18 Chang LW, Toth GP, Gordon DA, Graham DW, Meier JR, Knapp CW, DeNoyelles J Jr, Campbell S, Lattier DL. 2005. Responses of molecular indicators of exposure in mesocosms: Common carp (Cyprinus carpio) exposed to the herbicides alachlor and atrazine. Environ Toxicol Chem 24: 190–197.
- 19 Kim GB, Lee RF. 2004. Effects of genotoxic compounds on DNA and development of early and late grass shrimp embryo stages. Mar Environ Res 57: 329–338.
- 20 Jimenez BD, Oikari A, Adams SM, Hinton DE, McCarthy JF. 1990. Hepatic enzymes as biomarkers: Interpreting the effects of environmental physiological and toxicological variables. In JF McCarthy, LR Shugart, eds, Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA, pp 123–142.
- 21 Calow P, Forbes VE. 1998. How do physiological responses to stress translate into ecological and evolutionary processes? Comp Biochem Physiol A 120: 11–16.
- 22 Hyne RV, Maher WA. 2003. Invertebrate biomarkers: Links to toxicosis that predict population decline. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 54: 366–374.
- 23 Depledge MH. 1994. The rational basis for the use of biomarkers as ecotoxicological tools. In MC Fossi, C Leonzio, eds, Nondestructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA, pp 271–295.
- 24 Terriere LC. 1984. Induction of detoxication enzymes in insects. Annu Rev Entomol 29: 71–88.
- 25 Clark AG. 1989. The comparative enzymology of the glutathione S-transferases from non-vertebrate organisms. Comp Biochem Physiol B 92: 419–446.
- 26 Habig C, DiGiulio RT. 1991. Biochemical characteristics of cholinesterases in aquatic organisms. In P Mineau, ed, Cholinesterase-Inhibiting Insecticides: Their Impact on Wildlife and the Environment. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 19–33.
- 27 Willett KL, Wassenberg D, Lienesch L, Reichert W, Di Giulio RT. 2001. In vivo and in vitro inhibition of CYP1A-dependent activity in Fundulus heteroclitus by the polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbon fluoranthene. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 177: 264–271.
- 28 Martín-Díaz ML, Villena-Lincoln A, Bamber S, Blasco J, DelValls TA. 2005. An integrated approach using bioaccumulation and biomarker measurements in female shore crab, Carcinus maenas. Chemosphere 58: 615–626.
- 29 Klerks PL. 1987. Adaptation to metals in benthic macrofauna. PhD thesis. State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY, USA.
- 30 Brammell BF, Price DJ, Birge WL, Elskus AA. 2004. Apparent lack of CYP1A response to high PCB body burdens in fish from a chronically contaminated PCB site. Mar Environ Res 58: 251–255.
- 31 Ching EWK, Siu WHL, Lam PKSL, Xu L, Zhang Y, Richardson BJ, Wu RSS. 2001. DNA adduct formation and DNA strand breaks in green-lipped mussels (Perna viridis) exposed to benzo[a]pyrene: Dose- and time-dependent relationships. Mar Pollut Bull 42: 603–610.
- 32 Rondon MR, August PR, Bettermann AD, Brady SF, Grossman TH, Liles MR, Loiacono KA, Lynch BA, MacNeil IA, Minor C, Tiong CL, Gilman M, Osburne MS, Clardy J, Handelsman J, Goodman RM. 2000. Cloning the soil metagenome: A strategy for accessing the genetic and functional diversity of uncultured microorganisms. Appl Environ Microbiol 66: 2541–2547.
- 33 Van Straalen NM. 2003. Ecotoxicology becomes stress ecology. Environ Sci Technol 37: 324A–330A.
- 34 Forbes VE, Calow P. 1999. Is the per capita rate of increase a good measure of population-level effects in ecotoxicology? Environ Toxicol Chem 18: 1544–1556.
- 35
Caswell H.
2001.
Matrix Population Models,
2nd ed.
Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA, USA.
10.1111/j.1365-2745.2005.01077.x Google Scholar
- 36 Topping CJ, Hansen TS, Jensen TS, Jepsen JU, Nikolajsen F, Odderskær P. 2002. ALMaSS, an agent-based model for animals in temperate European landscapes. Ecol Model 167: 65–82.
- 37 Cagné F, Blaise C, Hellou J, 2004. Endocrine disruption and health effects of caged mussels, Elliptio complanata, placed downstream from a primary-treated municipal effluent plume for 1 year. Comp Biochem Physiol C 138: 33–44.
- 38
Sokal RR,
Rohlf FJ.
1995.
Biometry,
3rd ed.
W.H. Freeman, New York, NY, USA.
10.1577/1548-8659(1986)115<149:LOPDOR>2.0.CO;2 Google Scholar
- 39 Long ER, Buchman MF. 1990. A comparative evaluation of selected measures of biological effects of exposure of marine organisms to toxic chemicals. In JF McCarthy, LR Shugart, eds, Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA, pp 355–394.
- 40 Calabrese EJ. 2005. Paradigm lost, paradigm found: The re-emergence of hormesis as a fundamental dose response model in the toxicological sciences. Environ Pollut 138: 378–411.
- 41 Forbes VE. 2000. Is hormesis an evolutionary expectation? Funct Ecol 14: 12–24.
- 42 Sanders HL, Grassle JF, Hampson GR, Morse LS, Garner-Price S, Jones CC. 1980. Anatomy of an oil-spill: Long-term effects of the grounding of the barge Florida off West Falmouth, Massachusetts. J Mar Res 38: 265–380.
- 43 Grassle JF, Grassle JP. 1974. Opportunistic life histories and genetic systems in marine benthic polychaetes. J Mar Res 32: 253–284.
- 44 Gamenick I, Vismann B, Grieshaber MK, Giere O. 1998. Ecophysiological differentiation of Capitella capitata (Polychaeta). Sibling species from different sulfidic habitats. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 175: 155–166.
- 45 Linke-Gamenick I, Forbes VE, Méndez N. 2000. Effects of chronic fluoranthene exposure on sibling species of Capitella with different development modes. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 203: 191–203.
- 46 Linke-Gamenick I, Vismann B, Forbes VE. 2000. Effects of fluoranthene and ambient oxygen levels on survival and metabolism in three sibling species of Capitella (Polychaeta). Mar Ecol Prog Ser 194: 169–177.
- 47 Babson JR, Russo-Rodrigues SE, Wattley RV, Bergstein PL, Rastetter WH, Liber HL, Andon BM, Thilly WG, Wogan GN. 1986. Microsomal activation of fluoranthene to mutagenic metabolites. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 85: 355–366.
- 48 Rastetter WH, Nachbar RB, Russo-Rodriguez SE, Wattley RV, Thilly WG, Andon BM, Jorgensen WL, Ibrahim M. 1982. Fluoranthene: Synthesis and mutagenicity of four diol epoxides. J Org Chem 47: 4873–4878.
- 49 Shugart LR. 1995. Environmental genotoxicity. In GM Rand, ed, Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology, 2nd ed. Taylor & Francis, Washington, DC, USA, pp 405–420.
- 50 Palmqvist A, Selck H, Rasmussen LJ, Forbes VE. 2003. Biotransformation and genotoxicity of fluoranthene in the deposit-feeding polychaete Capitella sp. I. Environ Toxicol Chem 22: 2977–2985.
- 51 Bach L, Palmqvist A, Rasmussen LJ, Forbes VE. 2005. Comparative study on biotransformation, cellular distribution, genotoxicity, and acute cellular toxicity of the PAH, fluoranthene, in two marine polychaetes from the species complex Capitella capitata. Aquat Toxicol 74: 307–319.
- 52 McCarthy JF. 1990. Concluding remarks: Implementation of a biomarker-based environmental monitoring program. In JF McCarthy, LR Shugart, eds, Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, USA, pp 429–440.
- 53 Green JL, Hastings A, Arzberger P, Ayala FJ, Cottingham KL, Cuddington K, Davis F, Dunne JA, Fortin M-J, Gerber L, Neubert M. 2005. Complexity in ecology and conservation: Mathematical, statistical, and computational challenges. BioScience 55: 501–510.
- 54 Hastings A, Arzberger P, Bolker B, Collins S, Ives AR, Johnson NA, Palmer MA. 2005. Quantitative bioscience for the 21st century. BioScience 55: 511–517.
Citing Literature
